779 reviews · 776 verified
96% would recommend
5 ★
654
4 ★
85
3 ★
16
2 ★
10
1 ★
14

Reviews

What customers said

Page 25 of 78
Service date  2019-01-15
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Sharon

Great service, friendly staff and very trustworthy.

Sharon P. · Menasha, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2019-01-14
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Happy repeat customer

Great staff!

Stan P. · Neenah, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-12-26
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Good Job

Good place to go. Good service. Goodyear tires ride and handle well. Mileage is lower than with Firestone tires from before.

Paul R. · Neenah, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2019-01-12
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Oil Change Service

Thank you for always meeting my expectations!

Jasmin F. · Menasha, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2019-01-08
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Sandys review

Ive always had good service with Matthews. What I couldnt understand why his last time I had it in they said I had a couple leaks on the axle This time there was no report

Sandra P. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2019-01-07
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

A Review

Called Saturday noon, asked if they could fix headlites for trip. They worked me in, fixed it , I'm good . I have gone there for the 12 years I have been in Appleton and will continue because I like Jason, Craig and the others. But I don't know. Unless you can get chocalate donuts, with sprinkles, I don't know if just coffee........ Ya did good.

Michael C. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2019-01-03
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Immediate Response

My car did not start in my garage,I called Matthews and they sent a Tow truck in a short time. The next day I had my car returned to me, all repaired.

Joyce/Ted L. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-12-26
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Easy & Excellent Service

In the month I found one of my snow tires had a chuck missing from its tread and then I blew a tire on 41. In both cases they replaced them with a smile under the road hazard warranty I purchased with the tires. In the case of the blown tire I replaced it with my donut spare and brought the flat tire to Matthews where I purchased it. What I really appreciated is that when I opened my trunk a couple of days later they had put the donut back where it belonged and my truck was in perfect order. I've dealt with Matthews - Menasha for a few years now as they rotate and swap out my seasonal tires every 6 months or so and have found they are easy to deal with and deliver what they promise on time and with friendly professionalism. I also find they convey a very positive appreciation of my business regardless of whether it involves a purchase or a N/C service. Visit them twice in a month and you may even find they know you by name. ;-)

Wayne C. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-12-27
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

I have always got the best service from the staff. I have checked around and always come back here. I called late in the morning, dropped off the truck and by mid afternoon I was back on the road. Absolutely great experience.

Bob B. · Neenah, WI · Verified customer
Service date  2018-12-26
Verified Service Visit
Would recommend

Great service as always!

Took care of all my issues. I'm always confident that it's done right the first time!

Sandee F. · Appleton, WI · Verified customer

Also on Google

Google reviews

See this shop's Google rating and a few of its Google reviews, shown separately from the reviews above.